Best Bourbon Under $100 in Buffalo, NY (2026)

Buffalo House's buying team tastes through the bourbon aisle every season. These are the bottles we recommend under $100 — the ones our staff actually drinks at home.

Same-day delivery in Buffalo & nearby. Free on orders over $49 · $4.99 under · $25 minimum. Call (716) 770-1230 for tonight.

Our Picks

1. Henry McKenna 10 BiB — a staple of our bourbon selection.
2. Elijah Craig Barrel Proof — a staple of our bourbon selection.
3. Old Forester 1920 — a staple of our bourbon selection.
4. Booker's — a staple of our bourbon selection.
5. Stagg — a staple of our bourbon selection.
6. Russell's Reserve Single Barrel — a staple of our bourbon selection.
7. Four Roses Small Batch Select — a staple of our bourbon selection.
8. Michter's 10 Year — a staple of our bourbon selection.

How We Picked

Three filters: (1) it has to taste like more than its price tag suggests, (2) it has to be in stock most of the year, and (3) it has to be a bottle we'd hand a friend without hedging. No flippers, no hype-train pricing, no allocated unicorns on this list.

Browse the Full Bourbon Selection

Shop all bourbon → Need a recommendation under a different budget? Call (716) 770-1230.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the single best bourbon under $100?

Our top pick right now is Henry McKenna 10 BiB — but the best bottle is the one that fits your palate. Stop in or call us for a personal recommendation.

Are these in stock right now?

We restock weekly. If a specific bottle is out, call us — we'll often have it within a day.

Do you deliver these in Buffalo?

Yes — same-day delivery in the Buffalo metro. Free over $49.

Do you offer case discounts?

Yes — call (716) 770-1230 for case pricing on most bourbon.